E.l.f. Essentials Liquid Eyeliner review and swatches

Hi Girls,
When I first got this eyeliner, I wasn't very pleased by it, but after a few weeks of using it I actually start to like it.

My biggest cons of this product was that, I needed to be extra careful applying it on, because it has tendency to smudge a lot. After application, all my-very-inpatient-self had to do, was just wait a little bit - it dries up quick and stays on really good. 

I have 4 colors:  Midnight, Plum, Coffee and Black (last one is not on the pictures )

Midnight, Plum, Coffee

Pros:
+ good quality for the price - $1
+ like I said above, eyeliner stays on pretty good
+ easy to remove
+ good pigmentation

Cons:
- I was expecting brighter colors (plum looks more like a bright brown than a purple), they look different on the website, than in a real life.

+/- I don't like how thick applicator is, but It depends what you feel more comfortable with, I like very thin eyeliner brushes

have a fab day!
xox